Right?? It's weird how nail polishes can disappoint or surprise. Sometimes I get one I've been lemming for ages, and lose interest in it within 5 ticks of seeing the random one it came with that I'd gotten on a total whim.
Ahh that would be amazing!! I'm a little behind on what's new but there are 2 I have been trying to get my hands on without having to go online: OPI
Stay The Night & Revlon
Pumpkin Spice. I don't have high hopes for either, but those were at the top of my head. I searched all 3 Bed Bath & Beyonds near me and no Pumpkin Spice

I also need to have BB Couture
Vampy Varnish, but I might just crack and buy a bunch online soon. I am by no means picky though, I love surprises and I only hate 1 type of polish, which is frosty, but even those can have exceptions xD
What are you preferences, both candy and polish wise? I like chocolate 'o course, except the ones with fruity juices that ooze out...I dunno, those don't go down well for me. And sour candy forever! The more toxic the better

At the moment I am loving dusty creme jellies and super saturated jellies! Like, think Nars Zulu or Nfu Oh 569, but 5x brighter and juicier. I'm craving a deep, true green jelly that looks like hazardously delicious poison, but who knows when someone will finally invent it. I've been trying on my own but I think you need to start from scratch with a color like that

Maybe one day when I've retired early due to large sacks of money falling into my lap, I will go hunting for that perfect pigment.
I also like anything that reminds me of stars and the universe or generally requires a double take. I mashed together a bunch of pics of stuff I like, feel free to do the same! It would help me throw in more surprises
(yes, I like Scrangie very much!)In short: microglitter multichromatic jellies. And the adjectives just keep piling up as they poop out more and more complex weirdness. Speaking of which, I have been itching to just buy myself some chameleon pigment and mix my own multichromes. Alas, they only sell them in ridiculous quantities at a time for more money than I care to throw at them right after the holidays. But, now that I am thinking about it, perhaps, perhaps...
But yes, before this reply becomes a novel, I got lots of frankens, vintagey polishes, semi rares, international brands, magnetics, nail stickers, plates, and a smattering of others to throw into this mix. Also, I live near a lot of hipsters and have access to discounted Scotch Naturals, which are water based and don't smell like nail polish at all. Very weird, and very worth trying. I'll have to make a trip home this weekend to dig through endless boxes of colors, but I shall accumulate things in the coming days. Many, many things

Hell, I could even try making a custom color for you. Just let me know what you'd like, and I will mad scientist it awaayy~
p.s. manglaze makes me laugh